Sounak Banerjee Associate Content Manager
Associate Content Manager
The most important moment in the life of commerce students comes after completing BCom. Students realize that only BCom will not help them get a high-paying job and that another degree or course is very much necessary. The choice eventually comes between MBA or CA. CA and MBA are the best and most popular career paths after BCom. Courses after BCom may include MBA, CA, CS, CMA, CFA etc.
MBA is a 2 years postgraduate degree course, which is designed specifically for those who have work experience and want to learn more about how businesses operate. MBA is a prestigious degree and provides a number of career paths that can help people enhance their careers. MBA after BCom opens up various job opportunities across various positions such as Banker, Investment Banker, HR Manager along with an average starting salary of INR 3.35 LPA - 5 LPA annually. Check: MBA Jobs and Salary
Read More:
On the other hand, CA is a 5 year course whose demand in the international market is currently at an all-time high. As per a report by ICAI, 14% of the 2 lakh ICAI alumni are employed and settled abroad. The demand for CAs on the international market is comparable to that in India. For candidates who are considering beginning their career abroad, pursuing CA would be a fantastic choice for them. Some of the major job roles after completing CA include Cost Accountant, Chartered Accountant, Probationary Officer etc. The average starting salary for each job profile usually ranges between INR 4.55 LPA - 6 LPA annually. Read More: Salary of a Chartered Accountant
Discussed below is a detailed comparison between MBA and CA on the basis of various parameters such as eligibility criteria, admission process, scope, top colleges, salary etc.
Table of Content
7.1 MBA Scope
7.2 CA Scope
9.1 MBA Salary
9.2 CA Salary
10.1 Top MBA Colleges
10.2 Top CA Institutes
MBA vs CA: Quick Facts
Here is a quick table that will help the candidate to gather some quick facts about both the programs that will help to differentiate between the two courses for your better reference.
Parameters | MBA | CA |
---|---|---|
Degree | Post graduate | Professional Course |
Full form | Master of Business Administration | Chartered Accountancy |
Conducting Body | No Single Body | Institute of Chartered Accountants of India |
Duration | 2 years | 3 levels (CPT, IPCC and CA Final along with Article ship |
Age | 21 years and above | 17 years and above |
Minimum Eligibility | Bachelor's degree in any discipline preferably commerce | 10+2 from a recognized institute preferably commerce |
Average Fees | INR 9,000 – 8,00,000 | INR 9,000 - 36,000 |
Average Salary | INR 4 LPA | INR 5.25 LPA |
Employment Roles | Manager, Team Leader, Human resource Manager, Investment Banker | Chartered Accountant, Auditor, Finance manager, Chief Finance Controller etc |
Employment Sectors | Hotels, Hospitals, Banks, Financial institutions, Corporate offices etc | Corporate offices, Self practice, Financial institutions |
Career Options | Banker Bank Manager HR Manager Project Manager Investment Banker |
Chartered Accountant Cost Accountant Probationary Officer |
Top Recruiters | Accenture, Indegene Lifesystems, Jg Group, In Silico Biology, etc. | Ernst & Young, KPMG, Deloitte, HCL |
What is CA?
Chartered Accountancy is an internationally recognized professional course which in India is conducted by ICAI i.e. Institute of Chartered Accountants in India. To become a Chartered Accountant in India, candidates need to clear 3 stages: CPT, IPCC and CA Final along with Articleship.
- A candidate who clears all the stages of the exam is called a CA. Candidates can appear for the CPT exam after completing 10+2 .
- If the candidate wants to skip giving CPT exam, they can complete their graduation in any discipline and after that, they can directly appear for level two i.e. IPCC.
- CA is relatively a tough course as compared to other courses and requires full dedication and hard work. The average salary of a Chartered Accountant in India is around INR 8.06 LPA.
What is an MBA?
MBA or Master in Business Administration is a very vast course that offers various specializations. MBA is a 2 year postgraduate program which the candidate can opt to pursue from India as well as abroad.
There are several specializations offered through this course such as Marketing, Human Resource, Finance, International Business, Financial Management, Operations, etc.
Admission across top MBA colleges in India are conducted on the basis of various Management Entrance Exams such as, CAT, MAT, XAT, CMAT, ATMA, MHT CET etc.
MBA Vs CA: Admission process
The admission criteria of both MBA and CA is very different as MBA is a 2 year postgraduate program while chartered Accountant is a professional exam with a duration of 5 years (if cleared in one attempt). Let’s discuss the Admission process for both CA and MBA respectively.
CA Admission Process
Discussed below in detail is the CA Admission procedure in India for your better reference,
- The first and foremost step is that candidates are not required to take admission in any college, institution or university in order to pursue a CA course.
- However, students need to register themselves in ICAI by depositing requisite fees for the foundation course, 4 - 6 months prior to the first stage of exam i.e Common Proficiency test (CPT).
- Candidates who have completed 10+2 need to appear for the CPT exam which is held twice a year.
- If the candidate wants to skip this stage, then they must clear their graduation degree in order to appear for the second stage i.e IPCC.
- At every stage, the fees need to be submitted in order to enroll for the next stage.
- The candidate also needs to pursue Articleship which is for the duration of 3 years.
Check:
MBA Admission Process
Discussed below is the MBA Admission procedure for your reference,
- Candidates who have completed bachelor’s degree in any discipline can appear for the aforementioned course.
- The first and the foremost step to pursue an MBA is that the candidate must appear for the entrance exam in order to get admission in the top MBA colleges in India. Some of the entrance tests are CAT, MAT, XAT, CMAT etc.
- After appearing for the entrance exam, the candidate needs to check their score and according to that score the counseling is done.
- CAT is the top MBA entrance exam as it offers admission to IIMs in India.
- Once the score is released, candidates need to apply in the colleges on the basis of their rank.
- Several colleges conduct group discussions and personal Interview to test the abilities of the candidate and they are further marked and shortlisted on the basis of that score.
- The final list of the candidate is released and the offer letters are released to which the candidate needs to provide acceptance within a period of time.
MBA Vs CA: Eligibility Criteria
The eligibility criteria of both MBA and CA is quite different from each other. Let’s discuss in detail the eligibility criteria of both for your reference,
CA Eligibility Criteria
- In order to be eligible for the Chartered Accountancy course, the candidate must clear their 10+2 board exams in any stream from a recognized institute with a minimum score of 55% for commerce candidates and 60% for other candidates.
- Candidates need to get themselves registered at the Institute of Chartered ACcountants of India.
- The materials will be provided to the candidates after getting themselves registered.
- It is up to the wish of the candidate whether they want to take admission in any college or institution to pursue another degree.
- Candidates can also pursue CA course after the completion of the graduation to get directly into the second stage. Read More: CA Exams
MBA Eligibility Criteria
- Candidates must pursue their bachelor's degree in any discipline with a minimum aggregate score of 50% or above to pursue the program.
- There are several colleges in India that offer dual courses such as BBA with MBA with a duration of 5 years .
- Candidates also need to clear the entrance test for the purpose of getting admission in one of the top colleges in India such as CAT, MAT, XAT, etc. Check: MBA Eligibility
CA or MBA: Which is Better
The actual labor force for both CA and MBA have comparable respectability. In some industries, CAs are preferred above MBAs, and vice versa. Additionally, CA graduates take on more responsibilities than MBA graduates and pick up new abilities on the job. On the other hand MBA graduates are more in demand because of their Business management and data analytics skills. Read More: MBA Skills
Therefore, the decision of whether Chartered Accountancy or MBA is preferable for a student is entirely up to them. They should take into account aspects like their interests, preferred employment role, remuneration, career potential, and job security in order to make an informed choice. Discussed below are a few of the major differentiating factors between a CA and an MBA degree.
- CA is very cost efficient as the fees for the entire duration of pursuing the course is around INR 60,000 -70,000. While the fees of an MBA course is around INR 1,50,000 - 4,00,000.
- CA has a very limited scope in both private sector as well as public sector while MBA offers a lot of great opportunities in both the private as well as public sector
- Candidates do not require very high academic qualifications in order to be a CA. Candidates just need to clear the 3 stages of the program while the candidates pursuing MBA need to clear the first undergraduate degree rather than the entrance exam to finally get into any college of MBA.
- The average salary of a CA is much higher than an MBA . The average salary of a CA is around INR 8.06 LPA while the salary of a MBA Graduate is around INR 4 L - 5 LPA.
MBA Vs CA: Scope
MBA and CA both are top courses in India and are counted as the top choices amongst the candidates as well. The scope for both the courses are also vast and in great demand, both across the private sector as well as public sector.
Discussed below in detail the scope of both courses individually for your reference,
MBA Scope
- The scope of MBA is actually very vast and is in huge demand in both the private as well as public sector.
- MBA offers some of the very promising career choices to the candidates.
- MBA Graduates are employed across various industries starting from FMCG to Banking, media houses, banks and a lot more.
- Some of the top industries include Retail industry, advertising , automobile, healthcare, supply chain, information Technology, Finance industry, operations & project management, International Business, etc.
- They can be employed as Banker, Bank Manager, HR Manager, Project Manager, Investment Banker etc.
- According to Glassdoor, the average salary of an MBA graduate is around INr 4 LPA.
Read More:
CA Scope
- The scope for CA in India as well as abroad are very vast offering opportunities in a wide arena of industries. Candidates can be employed in both the private sector as well as the public sector.
- Candidates can start working right after completing the course with a very good salary package.
- Most of the CA are hired in Banks, Law Firms, Auditing Firms, public limited companies etc. Some of the top companies include Ernst & Young, KPMG, Deloitte, HCL etc. The average salary of a CA is around INR 8.06 LPA.
Check:
MBA vs CA: Duration
Tabulated below is the average duration for both the courses keeping in mind the entirety of both the courses for your reference.
MBA | CA |
---|---|
2 years | 5 years |
MBA vs CA: Salary
Some of the crucial factors that determine the salary of any profession are, experience, specialization, and the related working industry. Both MBA and CA graduates have a variety of job responsibilities, which entitles them to a wide range of pay.
Discussed below is the average salary for both MBA and CA graduates.
MBA Salary
According to Glassdoor, The starting salary of a MBA Graduate is around INR 3.00 LPA. The average salary package of an MBA graduate depends on a number of factors such as experience, academics, company profile, location, campus placement etc. After gaining relevant years of experience, the salary of an MBA graduate ranges from INR 7 L- 8 LPA. Read More: MBA Salary
Tabulated below is the salary of an MBA Graduate in India in various companies for your better reference.
Name of the Company | Average Annual Salary (INR) |
---|---|
Tata Consultancy Services | 9.4 L |
Accenture | 5.1 L |
HDFC Bank | 5.4 L |
Flipkart | 10.7 L |
Axis Bank | 5.5 L |
Randstad India | 6.0 L |
CA Salary
According To Payscale, the average salary of a Chartered Accountant in India is INR 8.06 LPA. The starting salary of a CA is INR 5 LPA which with gradual experience and expertise can go up to INR 78 L- 80 LPA. According to a report published by Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), the average CA salary rose from INR 8 L - 9 LPA offered through ICAI campus placements. Read More: CA Salary
Tabulated below is the salary of a Chartered Accountant in India in various companies for your better reference.
Name of the Company | Average Annual Salary (INR) |
---|---|
Deloitte | 10.48 L |
Ernst & Young | 11.10 L |
KPMG | 7.95 L |
Grant Thornton | 12.48 L |
PwC | 7.12 L |
TATA consultancy Services | 6.00 L |
ICICI Bank | 11.00 L |
MBA vs CA: Top Colleges
India is home to more than 5,000 MBA colleges which are both of private and public domain, on the other hand there are more than 35 CA Institutes.Discussed below are few of the top names for each domain for your reference.
Top MBA Colleges
Some of the top institutes include Indian Institute of Management, Faculty of Management Studies, IIT Delhi, etc. Tabulated below are some of the top colleges of MBA in India.
Name of the College | Average Fees |
---|---|
IIM Ahmedabad | 15,00,000 |
IIM Calcutta | 15,00,000 |
XLRI Jamshedpur | 5,00,000 |
Faculty of Management Studies | 5,00,000 |
IIT Delhi | 1,00,000 |
NITIE, Mumbai | 15,00,000 |
Symbiosis Institute of Management Studies | 12,00,000 |
IIM Indore | 11,00,000 |
IIM Kozhikode | 8,00,000 |
Amity Business School | 4,00,000 |
Top CA Institutes
Some of the top colleges of CA in India are tabulated below for your better reference,
Name of the College | Average Fees |
---|---|
Global Centre for Entrepreneurship & Commerce, Jaipur | 7,50,000 |
Christ University, Bangalore | 6,85,000 |
Symbiosis College of Arts and Commerce | 4,00,000 |
Apeejay Stya University | 4,68,000 |
Sharda University | 11,00,000 |
MBA vs CA: FAQs
Ques. Is MBA and CA both the same degree?
Ans. No, CA is a professional course while MBA is an academic course. Although both are one of the top courses in the finance and business sector, both are very different courses from each other.
Ques. Is CA course hard as compared to MBA?
Ans. Yes, CA courses are relatively tough as compared to other courses. The course requires great hardwork and dedication as the IPCC and Final levels are very tough.
Ques. What skills are required to become a Chartered Accountant ?
Ans. Some of the top skills that are required to become a Chartered Accountant are:
- Knowledge of accounting and auditing
- Excellent Communication
- Knowledge of socio economic conditions’
Ques. What skills are required that a MBA graduate should possess?
Ans. Some of the top skills that are required for the MBA Graduate are,
- Pressure handling
- Decision Making
- Leadership qualities
- Time management
- Uplifted work values
Ques. What are the career options after completing MBA?
Ans. Some of the top career choices are:
- Marketing manager
- Financial advisor
- Analyst
- Administrative manager
- Investment banking
Ques. What are the entrance tests to get into a top MBA college?
Ans. Some of the top entrance to get into top MBA college are:
- CAT
- MAT
- XAT
- SET
Ques. What are the job prospects after completing CA course?
Ans. The job prospects after completing CA course are;
- Auditing Firms & Taxation
- Management Consultancy services
- Corporate law
- Banking
Ques. Name the top MBA college?
Ans. Some of the top MBA colleges are
- IIM
- SYmbiosis Institute of Management Studies
- IIT Delhi
- Chandigarh University
Ques. how many levels are there to clear CA exam?
Ans. There are almost 4 levels to clear the CA - CPT, IPCC, CA final and then 3 years of Articleship.
Ques. What is the Highest salary of a CA ?
Ans. The Highest salary of a CA is around INR 78 L - 80 LPA. As CA also self practice , their salary might even go in crores.
Comments