You can judge for yourself, which is the best college for an MBA based on certain parameters.
Deciding Factors:
Some of these parameters are as follows.
Comparison:
A brief comparison between BIMM Pune, MNIT Jaipur, BIT Mesra, and IMS Ghaziabad is given below.
Category |
BIMM Pune |
MNIT Jaipur |
BIT Mesra |
IMS Ghaziabad |
Ranking |
11th Times B- School 2020 |
71st by NIRF 2020 |
85th by NIRF 2020 |
14th Times B-School |
Average CTC |
6 LPA |
4.66 LPA |
4.5 LPA |
6 LPA |
Highest CTC |
14 LPA |
5.79 LPA |
10.2 LPA |
16.5 LPA |
Top recruiters |
Andhra Bank, Bluestar, Britannia, Dabur, Deloitte |
Goldman Sachs, Walmart, Salesforce, Accenture, |
TATA AIG, Bandhan Bank, ICICI Bank, Prism Johnson, ICICI Prudential |
Deloitte, Federal Bank, ITC, Ernest and Young, ICICI Group |
Entrance |
CAT/MAT/XAT |
CAT/MAT/XAT |
CAT/MAT/XAT |
CAT/MAT/XAT |
CAT cutoff |
70 percentile |
- |
40 percentile |
75 percentile |
Fees |
Rs. 8.75 lakhs |
Rs. 3.18 lakhs |
Rs. 5.54 lakhs |
Rs. 7.95 lakhs |
All the colleges are good for an MBA and have something unique to offer. Based on the given information, you can decide which college meets your needs and preferences.
BIMM Pune is one of the best Management colleges in Pune. It offers better ROI compared to IBS Hyderabad and SIMC Pune.
IBS Hyderabad is a NAAC ‘A’ grade institute and consistently ranked among the top B-Schools in India. IBS provides a synthesis of Indian and International perspectives, emphasis on case-based learning, Business Modelling and simulation and creates a strong industry interface.
SIMC Pune is one of the few colleges offering an MBA in Communications Management. They offer 4 specializations under the communications management program - Brand Communication, Public Relations, Marketing, and Media Analytics, Media Management.
Given below is a brief comparison between the three institutes.
Categories |
BIMM Pune |
IBS Hyderabad |
SIMC Pune |
Established |
1999 |
1995 |
1991 |
Accredited by |
AICTE |
SAQS, AACSB |
AICTE |
Rank |
#46 (India Today) |
#25 (India Today) |
#3 (for Mass Communications by India Today) |
Exams accepted for admission |
CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT/MAH MBA CET |
IBSAT, CAT/GMAT/NMAT by GMAC |
SNAP |
Selection |
Group Discussion, Personal Interview, and Essay Writing |
Group Discussion, Personal Interview |
Group Exercise, Personal Interaction, Written Ability Test |
MBA Course Fee |
8.45 lakhs |
14.04 lakhs |
10.05 lakhs |
Placement Percentage |
95% |
96% |
95.45%. |
Highest Salary Package |
14 LPA |
16.05 LPA |
13 LPA |
Average Salary Package |
6.8 LPA |
7.32 LPA |
4.78 LPA |
SIMC Pune unlike the other two colleges has a specialized MBA program. If you find Communications Management interesting you can opt for it. Otherwise, BIMM Pune or IBS Hyderabad will be a better choice.
Sri Balaji Society (BIMM) Pune
Sri Balaji Society (BIMM) Pune is a premier management institute offering a full-time MBA degree course. The university has four management institutions - BIMM, BITM, BIIB, and BIMHRD. It is one of the leading MBA colleges in Pune. The institute was ranked as one of the top 6 Private B-Schools in India by TOI B-School Survey, 2019.
The table below gives an overview of the MBA programs offered by the institute.
Specializations |
General, IT & Marketing, PM & HRD, Executive |
Admission |
CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT/MAH-CET score, Group Discussion, Personal Interview |
Course fee |
8.45 lakhs |
Placement achieved |
95% |
Highest package |
INR 15 LPA |
Average package |
INR 8 LPA |
Top Recruiters |
Google, SBI, Colgate, Amazon, HCL, Accenture, Mindtree, Deloitte, etc. |
BIMTECH Noida
NIRF has ranked BIMTECH 47th for MBA. BIMTECH’s PGDM-IB program is quite good. The program not only helps students to acquire new skills but also to integrate these concepts on a higher level. The PGDM-IB program is AICTE accredited and the course curriculum includes case studies, management simulation, quizzes, live projects, panel discussions, industry visits, etc.
Given below is the IB course highlights as offered by BIMTECH Noida:
Admission |
CAT/XAT/GMAT score, Personal Interview, and Written Test |
Course fee |
11.5 lakhs |
Placement achieved |
90% |
Highest package |
INR 12 LPA |
Average package |
INR 7.5 LPA |
Top Recruiters |
Genpact, Pepsi, Ola, Barclays, Whirlpool, Birlasoft, Wipro, etc. |
Both Sri Balaji Society Pune, BIMTECH are reputed management institutes. BIMTECH offers good industry exposure and concise batch strength. Whereas BIMM offers better ROI.
Jaipuria College Lucknow and Balaji Institute of Modern Management, Pune, or BIMM are among the premier B-Schools in India. Both the institutes have their advantages.
Jaipuria College of Lucknow offers NBA accredited PGDM programs. It is also recognized by AIU. The PGDM programs offered by the institute are equivalent to MBA. On the other hand, the Balaji Institute of Modern Management is one of the top 3 B-schools in Pune. Also, compared to Jaipuria College of Lucknow, BIMM offers better ROI.
Given below is a brief comparison between the two institutes.
Categories |
Jaipuria College Lucknow |
Balaji Institute of Modern Management Pune |
Established |
1995 |
1999 |
Accreditation |
AICTE, AIU, NBA |
AICTE |
Rank |
73 (NIRF) |
46 (NIRF) |
Intake |
700+ |
360 |
Course fee (1st-year fee) |
4.7 lakh |
4.45 lakh |
Exams Required |
CAT, CMAT, MAT, ATMA, GMAT, XAT |
CAT, MAT, XAT, CMAT, MH-CET |
Selection |
Group Discussion, Personal Interview |
Group Discussion, Essay Writing, Personal Interview |
Placement Percentage |
98% |
95% |
Highest Salary Package |
18.05 LPA |
14 LPA |
Average Salary Package |
6.7 LPA |
7 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Johnson & Johnson, Deloitte, Reckitt Benckiser, IDFC Bank, ITC, HCL Technologies, Wipro, Asian Paints. |
Deloitte, Infosys, ITC, TCS, Panasonic, HUL, Aditya Birla Group, Reliance, UltraTech, Wipro. |
Total Companies Participated |
375+ |
337 |
The PGDM program of BIMM provides the latest curriculum interwoven with industry needs and expectations which enables the students to stay updated with the industry trends. Whereas, MET Mumbai uses the iconic lineage of the MBA program along with the new age technological inputs to make the students ready for today’s digital business framework for the PGDM (e-business) course.
Given below is a comparison between the PGDM programs offered by BIMM Pune and MET Mumbai.
Categories |
BIMM |
MET Mumbai |
Established |
1999 |
1989 |
Accredited by |
AICTE |
AICTE |
Rank |
#46 (India Today) |
#31 (Times B School) |
Specializations |
General, IT & Marketing, PM & HRD, Executive |
Marketing, Finance, HR and Operating Systems |
Qualifying Exams |
CAT, MAT, XAT, CMAT, MH-CET. |
MH-CET, CMAT, XAT, CAT, ATMA, GMAT, MAT. |
Selection |
Group Discussion, Personal Interview, and Essay writing |
Personal Interview (If required) |
Course Fee |
8.45 lakhs |
8 lakhs |
Placement Percentage |
95% |
75% |
Highest Salary Package |
14 LPA |
15.5 LPA |
Average Salary Package |
6.85 LPA |
7.5 LPA |
Top Recruiters |
Vedanta, Indus Towers, Colgate, TAFE, Palmolive, Deloitte, Infosys, Accenture, Mindtree, Google, Wipro, etc. |
Nielsen, The Times of India, Zee Entertainment, Hindustan Unilever Limited, Reliance, Edelweiss, Aditya Birla Group, Radio City, etc. |
Both colleges provide students with similar facilities and have more or less the same approach towards academics. BIMM provides a more traditional outlook of Management studies, unlike MET. Also, BIMM is a bigger brand name and offers better ROI as compared to MET Mumbai.
BIMM Pune is a premier management institute in Pune. It is affiliated to Sri Balaji University. PGDM Executive is the specialty of BIMM and Finance is among the best specializations offered by the institute.
Course Structure:
Admission and Eligibility:
Placements:
BIMM Pune is a reputed institute for an Executive MBA program. The faculty are well-qualified and have experience of 10-15 years or more. BIMM also offers a good Return on Investment.
BIMM Pune is a better management institute compared to MITSOB.
In terms of academics, placements, exposure, BIMM Pune is better.
SIBM Pune and BIMM Pune have been ranked at 6th and 11th among private MBA colleges by Outlook 2020 respectively. Both the institutes are well recognized and are famous B-schools.
The table mentioned below gives a brief overview of both institutes:
PARTICULARS |
SIBM PUNE |
BIMM PUNE |
OWNERSHIP |
Private |
Private |
TOTAL COURSES |
5 Courses across 2 streams |
4 courses in 3 streams |
DURATION |
2 Years |
2 Years |
TOTAL FEES |
INR 17.26 Lakh |
INR 8.45 Lakh |
POPULAR COURSES |
MBA/PGDM, Executive MBA/PGDM |
MBA/PGDM, Executive MBA/PGDM |
SEATS BREAK UP |
120 |
180 |
ENTRANCE EXAM |
SNAP |
CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT or MAH |
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA:
In BIMM Pune, the aspirants are required to have a minimum of 50% in aggregate in graduation. While in SIBM Pune the candidates are required to have 60% in aggregate in graduation.
The weightage assigned to all stages of the admission process is as follows.
BASIS |
SIBM PUNE |
BIMM PUNE |
ENTRANCE EXAM SCORE |
50 |
35 |
GD AND WAT |
20 |
35 |
PI |
30 |
30 |
PLACEMENTS:
PARTICULARS |
SIBM PUNE |
BIMM PUNE |
HIGHEST PACKAGE OFFERED |
INR 34.26 LPA |
INR 14 LPA |
AVERAGE PACKAGE |
INR 20.08 LPA |
INR 6 LPA |
TOP RECRUITERS |
Bajaj Finery, AVIVA, IBM, Pidilite, HDFC Bank, DELL, etc. |
Amazon, Bajaj allianz, Capital First Ltd, HCL Technologies, etc. |
% of students placed |
98% of students placed until now |
95% of students placed until now. |
INFRASTRUCTURE: SIBM Pune has a multi-cuisine cafeteria and is highly maintained and the food is hygienic too. The hostel facility is up to date and the classrooms are well spacious and are fully air-conditioned. Moreover, all the labs are well equipped. On the other hand, BIMM Pune has a well-stocked library and the hostel services and canteen are excellent and the sports complex is very big and the classrooms are well equipped.
Both colleges are private institutions and are considered amongst Tier-2 colleges for an MBA degree. We look at this exhaustive comparison through bullets and tables to compare the two.
Pointers |
BIMM |
XIME |
Total Fees (2 Yrs.) |
8.45 Lakhs |
10 Lakhs |
Rankings (Business Today) |
46 |
56 |
Companies Visiting |
Adani, Amazon, Deloitte, HCL, ICICI, Capital First etc. |
Accenture, KPMG, Deloitte, Muthoot, Godrej, etc. |
Overall Placement Rate |
95% |
94% |
Avg. Salary Offered |
6 LPA |
6.5-7 LPA |
Hostel Availability |
Yes |
Yes |
No. of Seats |
120 |
180 |
Closing Percentile |
N.A* |
CAT- 70%ile MAT- 85%ile CMAT- 80%ile |
*The college does not judge students on the basis of the score granted by any entrance exam. Hence, no cut off score.
Eligibility: A graduate from a UGC recognized university with 50% marks is eligible for admission to the course at both the places. Plus, the score of any exam from CAT/ MAT/ XAT/ CMAT is considered.
Admissions Process: A shortlist is prepared of candidates with a valid score in any exam amongst CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT in both the colleges. The GD+Essay Writing followed by Personal Interview after the shortlist completes the process. BIMM also accepts the score of MAH CET and XIME considers ATMA and GMAT scores.
Course Curriculum: Following the pattern of London Business School with emphasis on producing industry ready candidates, BIMM appears appealing. At the same time, positive reviews regarding Academic engagement at XIME presents the curriculum in a bright light.
Other: The location of XIME being Bangalore, it claims being accessible to giants in the industry, thus ensuring better placements for students. As far as 'Student Life' is concerned, less focus on extracurricular activities, presents XIME in a bad light compared to BIMM.
To conclude, with a low RoI, XIME here seems to fall short in comparison to BIMM but covers up in academics and faculty.
BIMM Pune and Alliance Business School, Bangalore are great colleges for management studies. Both colleges have their strong points.
Some important details are tabulated below for both the institutes.
Category |
BIMM Pune |
Alliance B School |
Average CTC |
INR 6 LPA |
INR 7.6 LPA |
Highest CTC |
INR 14 LPA |
INR 22 LPA |
Entrance |
CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT |
GMAT/CMAT/CAT |
CAT Cutoff |
70 percentile |
85 percentile |
Intake |
420 |
400 |
Comparison: (Winning Institute - BIMM Pune)
In terms of course fees, ROI, and academics, BIMM Pune is the better college choice. If you are from a middle-class family, Alliance B School can be costly for you. Also, the ROI of Alliance is not that good and it will be difficult to repay your loans. Based on the information, you can make your decision.