You should first consider the branch and then look at the college that you want to go to. Go through the brochures, as well as whatever information is available on the website, that will provide details about the course structure. This will help you gain a brief idea about what you can expect in the next four years of your academic life, and if it suits you.
Half your battle is conquered if you have an interest in what you are studying. College rankings, average packages, and statistics will not help you much other than provide a brief overview regarding the college.
Comparison:
Do your research and see which college suits you better, fees and course-wise. Then make a decision.
BITS Pilani and IIT BHU are considered among the best engineering colleges in the country. You can choose either of these two based on your choice of branch. Here is a brief comparison of both institutes.
Both institutes have their advantages. You should talk to the current students regarding your branch, before choosing one of these two institutes.
Old IITs like Delhi, Mumbai, Kharagpur, Madras, and Kanpur rank higher than BITS Pilani. If you are getting admission to any of these IITs, go for it.
IITs like Dhanbad, BHU, Guwahati, Roorkee, and BITS Pilani belong in the same category. So, go where you are getting your preferred branch.
BITS is much better than the new IITs like Jammu, Mandi, Patna, Jodhpur, Goa, Pallakad, and Indore.
BITS offers an excellent campus experience which helps in overall personality development. As a student of the institute, you will have the freedom to study and explore any interest you have.
Both institutes are among the top institutions in India. So decide accordingly based on the following factors -
According to NIRF Ranking 2019, BITS Pilani is ranked at 39 and IIT BHU at 28. So the numbers show that IIT BHU has performed better over BITS Pilani in terms of infrastructure, faculties, research facilities, outreach, and location.
The IITs being run by the government body, the fee structure is less as compared to BITS Pilani. Also being government institutions, IITs have fee waiver schemes available, unlike BITS.
Electrical at IIT BHU includes only the core electrical subjects which is why a lot of the students end up preparing for software/hardware companies for the placement with a decent package since there are few companies employing core electrical students. On the other hand, BITS Pilani has a combined electrical and electronics engineering course which provides students with the knowledge of both the areas as the industry demands so and also provides opportunities in various areas. So if you are interested in learning more and in-depth about the subject, BITS Pilani should be the choice. Being a private institute, they have very flexible and effective course structures.
Overall, both the institute has good faculties. However, when it comes to IIT BHU since it is an older institute, it has many well-experienced faculties. Moreover, IITs lead in the research facilities as well as in research work.
Both institutes provide good placement opportunities to their students. According to 2019 placement statistics, a total of 88 students got placed from Electrical in IIT BHU. The average CTC ranged between 10 LPA to 58.21 LPA. While in BITS Pilani the placement percentage of EEE was around 59.3% with an average CTC of 14.86 LPA. If you are interested in MS after B.Tech, then BITS-Pilani would be better. Though IITs are popular worldwide, it is better to have the BITS tag for doing MS. If you are planning for an M.Tech or research-oriented career in India, IIT BHU is better.
Both institutes offer a huge alumni network. BITS has many alumni working in foreign, international brands. However, the alumni network of IIT BHU is a little larger since it is older and its alumni are present in every possible career paths.
BITS Pilani is a NAAC and UGC accredited reputed institute and is also a member of AIU. BITS Pilani has been recognized as an Institute of Eminence and is also one of the institutes to follow “no reservation policy.” BITS Pilani and NIT Surathkal have been ranked 30th and 13th for Engineering by NIRF 2020.
Admission:
Admission to the BE Mechanical program at BITS Pilani is done through the BITSAT score while at NIT Surathkal BTech Mechanical admission is done through the JEE mains score.
Mechanical Engineering at NIT Surathkal and BITS Pilani:
The Mechanical Engineering department of BITS Pilani is DST-FIST and UGC-SAP sponsored with strong collaborations with industry and premium institutes all over the globe.
Faculties at the Mechanical Engineering department of BITS Pilani are Ph.D. holders with past experience in teaching, industry, and research. Prof. P.Srinivasan of the Mechanical Engineering department was felicitated with the “Prof.S.S.Ranganathan Memorial Teaching Excellence Award 2017.”
NITKRacing, a racing team from the mechanical engineering department participated in the FS Hungary 2012 and bagged an overall position of 33rd. This racing team is funded by giant companies like Bosch, Quest, and Daimler.
BAJA consists of dedicated students from the mechanical engineering department of NIT Surathkal who are aimed at constructing an All-Terrain Vehicle(ATV) to participate in the BAJA Challenge.
Prof. Srikanth Bontha from Mechanical Engineering from NITK has been awarded the 2010 Outstanding Young Manufacturing Engineer Award by the Society of Manufacturing Engineers(SME).
Placement:
The placement details for Mechanical Engineering at the institute are as follows.
Criteria |
NIT Surathkal |
BITS Pilani |
Students Placed |
95% |
90% |
Median Salary |
8 LPA |
12.5 LPA |
Top recruiters at NIT Surathkal include Adobe, Amazon, CenturyLink, CITI Bank, Deloitte, Fidelity, Oracle, and VISA while top recruiters at BITS Pilani include Accenture, Axis Bank, Amazon, Bajaj Allianz, Cyient, CISCO Systems, CapGemini, etc.
Alumni:
Notable alumni of NIT Surathkal include Rajeev Madhavan- Founder of Magma Design Automation. Other notable alumni include Thomas Zacharia who is a renowned Indian-American Computer Scientist.
Notable alumni of BITS Pilani include S.P Kothari- Professor at MIT Sloan School of Management and Padma Shri Award Winner. Other notable alumni include Baba Kalyani who is Chairman and Managing Director of Bharat Forge.
Both the departments are of high repute with mass placement drive. So, choose according to your convenience.
Both IIT Kanpur Electrical and BITS Pilani CS are excellent choices yet, if I had to choose one, I would have opted for BITS Pilani CS. Here’s why,
Today, CS is one of the most preferred domains and its demand is growing at a very fast rate in the job market. For anyone whose ultimate goal is high packages in top firms, CS should be the only choice. No other branch can fetch you packages as high as CS.
As a BITS Pilani student, you can access the extensive alumni pool and develop strong networks in industries. Also, the CS placements at BITS Pilani are top-notch
Particulars |
Data |
Number of students placed |
18 |
Number of companies |
46 |
Highest CTC |
INR 38 LPA |
I wouldn't suggest you go for ECE IIT Roorkee unless you are genuinely interested in that field and want to pursue a career in it.
Both IIT Roorkee and BITS Pilani are excellent engineering colleges and it’s difficult to compare them. However, I would like to point out some basic differences
Fees: BITS Pilani fees are around 20-25 Lakhs whereas that of Roorkee is almost half around 10 lakhs. Considering the ROI, IIT Roorkee is a much better choice.
Campus life: IIT Roorkee organizes better fests at a much larger scale than BITS Pilani. Also, IIT Roorkee is in close proximity to tourist spots such as Mussoorie and Rishikesh, making them a good weekend getaway.
Exposure: Being a government Institution, IIT Roorkee offers better exposure in terms of research work and you can find most of the professors here working on projects. However, the alumni base and startup culture is better at BITS Pilani.
Coding and Dev Community: IIT Roorkee has an edge in this aspect because of its number of GSOC selections(highest in India) and also Top finishes in ICPC every year.
Infrastructure: The government-funded institute, IIT Roorkee has better-equipped labs and computer facilities.
Academics: BITS Pilani does not have any strict attendance rules giving enough flexibility to students to explore beyond academics. However, branch change is much easier at IIT Roorkee than Placements. IIT Roorkee has the best opportunities in the IT sector. For those willing to pursue a career in Software development, IIT Roorkee is the best place.
Placements |
IIT Roorkee |
BITS Pilani |
Highest CTC |
INR 1.3 CPA |
INR 60.75 LPA |
Number of Recruiters |
63 |
109 |
Top Recruiters |
BCG, Bajaj Auto, Flipkart, Tata Steel |
Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Visa, Adobe, Cisco |
Internships: BITS Pilani provides good internship opportunities in the 2nd and 3 rd year owing to its practice school system.
Overall, both institutes give a constant edge to each other and one should consider their personal preferences before making the final decision.
It is difficult to say which is better, BITS Pilani or IIT Roorkee, as they are both highly respected institutions in India. Both universities have strong programs in engineering, technology, and science.
However, BITS Pilani is known for its focus on undergraduate education, while IT Roorkee is known for its research programs. Yet if I was to choose one, I would have chosen BITS Pilani for BTech
However, if you are someone who is interested in MTech in core branches or is inclined towards research work, then IIT Roorkee has a better research culture. Moreover, the extremely high fees at BITS Pilani might be a demotivating factor for many making IIT Roorkee a much better choice.
Placement-wise, IIT Bombay is clearly the winner, followed by IIT Delhi with IIIT Hyderabad and BITS Pilani almost similar
Particulars |
IIT Bombay |
IIT Delhi |
IIIT Hyderabad |
BITS Pilani |
Highest CTC |
INR 4 CPA |
INR 4 CPA |
INR 74 LPA |
INR 60.75 LPA |
Average CTC |
INR 23.26 LPA |
INR 1.25 CPA |
INR 32 LPA |
INR 30.37 LPA |
Top Recruiters |
American Express, Honda Japan, Mc Kinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group |
Jane Street |
Bloomberg, Code Nation, Deloitte, Facebook, Google, HSBC, Indeed |
Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Visa, Adobe, Cisco |
Courses: Course-wise too, IIT Bombay wins the race accompanied by IIT Delhi, IIIT Hyderabad, and BITS Pilani subsequently.
International competitions: The order remains the same except BITS scores better than IIIT Hyderabad in this aspect.
Startup culture: The startup culture too is best at IIT Bombay, then IIT Delhi followed by BITS and Hyderabad.
\Alumni: IIT Bombay has the highest number of successful alumni across the globe after which stands IIT Delhi, BITS Pilani, and finally IIIT Hyderabad.
I don’t think it’s logical to compare extremely old and government-funded IITs with private institutes like BITS and IIIH. The alumni reach is also incomparable.