It depends on your expectations. Doing a PGCBM will certainly be a good addition to your resume. You will get to learn from some of the leading professionals in the field of management. You will also get the opportunity to network with XLRI alumni. You can benefit a lot if you have a start-up idea and want to learn the ropes of management.
But getting better job offers based on the certification can be difficult. A PGCBM is not as valuable as the flagship programs offered by XLRI, in terms of immediate improvement in career outcomes.
XLRI offers a two years Human Resource program at PGD level and Symbiosis Pune offers an MBA and a Diploma in HR Management. The XLRI program has been ranked the best in Asia Pacific. Both institutes receive employment offers from names like Citibank, Yes Bank, Axis Bank, Mercer, Ranbaxy, Dabur etc.
The table below shows the information on the institute and programs-
Parameters |
XLRI (HR) |
Symbiosis Pune (HR) |
Placement Percentage |
100 |
100 |
Campus size (acres) |
50 |
300 |
Total Seats |
120-180 |
182 |
Fee |
INR 4.10-23.0 LPA |
INR 2.3 - 6.15 LPA |
Average Package |
INR 23 LPA |
INR 27.18 LPA |
Admission Process
Infrastructure and Faculty
Both institutes have 5 - 10 faculty members with NET and PhD qualifications.
Placement Details
Students can make a choice based on facts listed above in coherence with future goals.
Here is the XLRI admission process in brief.
The final selection is based on performance in XAT, Group Discussion, Personal Interviews, past academics, and relevant work experience.
IIFT is an excellent institution not particularly in India but also in Asia. It is a 55-year-old institution under the ministry of commerce and has the best to offer in areas of International Business and Foreign trade. ISB is quite reputed among students. The global ranking is the selling point and XLRI carries class and quality. It depends on what specialization you want to choose.
The table shows a brief overview of the institutions.
Particulars |
XLRI Jamshedpur |
ISB Hyderabad |
IIFT Delhi |
Median Salary |
INR 15 LPA |
INR 25.7 LPA |
INR 18.20 LPA |
Entrance Criteria |
XAT/GMAT |
GMAT / GRE |
IIFT |
Fees |
Rs. 4.26 Lakh |
Rs. 37.49 Lakh |
Rs. 7.6 Lakh |
Comparison:
So, choose the institute based on your choice of specialization.
Comparing XLRI and IIM Lucknow in terms of placements can be difficult unless you have personally gone through the process at either institution. Both institutions have a variety of firms that come to recruit from them. However, it depends on your career aspirations and interests. If your focus is on HR, XLRI is the better option. However, if your interests lie in other areas such as marketing and finance, IIM Lucknow may be a better fit as it has more firms that regularly visit across these domains, particularly in consulting.
In terms of infrastructure, IIM Lucknow has better on-campus facilities for both recreation and academics. However, it is worth noting that the infrastructure at both institutions should not present significant problems.
Finally, when considering the alumni network, the IIM tag opens more doors. XLRI is a well-respected brand, but the sheer number of IIM Lucknow alumni in the job market makes it stand out.
In conclusion, the decision between XLRI and IIM Lucknow largely depends on whether or not you want to study HR. If you do, XLRI is the better option, otherwise, IIM Lucknow is a better choice in terms of placements, infrastructure, and alumni network.
XLRI Jamshedpur and SP Jain Mumbai are both renowned management colleges in India, with XLRI having an edge due to its older establishment.
If you enjoy managing people and prioritize teamwork, a career in HRM may suit you well. It's worth noting that HRM has evolved to be much more than just headhunting.
Before making a final decision, it's important to consider the type of organization you would like to work with, if that's your goal post-MBA. This can help you make a more informed and beneficial decision.
XLRI offers a 15 month, full-time residential program. It is one of XLRI'S flagship programs accredited by the AMBA. It includes a 3 months field training as well. Each batch has only 101 students selected on merit.
SP Jain's PGDM program is a 2-year program accredited by AMBA and NBA as well. This program allows flexibility in changing the major as well.
Here's an overview of the three institutes:
Parameters |
GL (PGPM) |
XLRI (PGDM) |
SP Jain PGDM |
Placement rate |
100% |
100% |
100% |
Campus size |
27 acres |
50 acres |
45 acres |
Total Seats |
240 |
360 |
240 |
Fee |
11-15 LPA |
23 LPA |
17.50 LPA |
Average Package |
13.6 LPA |
24.3 LPA |
22 LPA |
Special Facts on Infrastructure and Program
SP Jain
GL Bajaj
XLRI
Placement Data 2020
XLRI
GL PGPM
SP Jain
Students can decide on a program based on the convenience of location and placements provided.
ISB PGPM is a one-year-long program. This program is better suited for students with few years of work experience. Compared to the other institutes, ISB charges a higher course fee. The total course fee for PGPM is INR 36.30 Lakhs.
The placement record of the institute is pretty good. ISB placements 2022 ended with an average CTC of around INR 34.07 LPA.
Compared to FMS, XLRI, JB, ISB is relatively new. So, it has a smaller alumni network.
When considering MBA programs, XLRI is a top choice and better than both SP Jain and IIM Lucknow due to its strong academic curriculum and excellent facilities. It is not only known for its Human Resources (HR) program, which is considered to be the best in India, but also for its Business Management (BM) program, which has a strong track record of 100% placement year after year. Additionally, XLRI has a wide range of placement opportunities for its students. Overall, XLRI is a well-rounded choice for an MBA program.
The median salary offered to students in the batch of XLRI was INR 30 lakhs per annum, with the top 10th percentile averaging INR 48 lakhs per annum and the top 25th percentile averaging INR 43 lakhs per annum. The top segments for roles offered were Consulting, ITES, E-Commerce, Gaming & Online Services, and Sales & Marketing. XLRI is highly regarded as the best institution in the country for Human Resources (HR) education. HR roles were offered by a wide range of companies, including P&G, HUL, ITC, Colgate Palmolive, Marico, JP Morgan Chase and Co., Google, Samsung, Bajaj Auto, Myntra, Ola, and others. The HR roles offered include HR Consulting, Recruitment, Compensation & Benefits, HR Analytics, and Chief of Staff. Premier consulting firms like PwC, EY, and Deloitte open exclusive HR consulting roles for XLRI students, further emphasizing the trust placed in XLRI graduates as future HR leaders.
XLRI Jamshedpur has been ranked 1st for Management programs by NIRF amongst the private institutions of the country. It offers PGDM programs in BM and HRM, which are Business Management and Human Resource Management respectively, that are two-year full-time programs.
Admissions:
Particulars |
PGDM in Business Management |
PGDM in Human Resource Management |
Total seats |
180 |
180 |
Fees |
INR 23.60 L |
INR 23.60 L |
Curriculum:
PGDM BM:
PGDM HRM:
Placements:
PGDM BM:
PGDM HRM:
Both these specializations are highly ranked by both national and international authorities. Business Management is its flagship course, but faculties of all courses are highly qualified, few being advisors to RBI, World Bank and UN. It is on the individual to carefully choose a course after comparing all factors and work diligently to excel in that field.