Most of the top B-schools in the country select candidates on the basis of CAT and to an extent, XAT. Since the aim of all the students is to get into the old IIMs, so there are a lot of amazing candidates who only sit for the CAT. Since the only way to get into SIBM/ SCMHRD is through SNAP, there is a perception that the best candidates do not prefer to go into these institutions, which is not necessarily true but might explain the public perception. Also, with the introduction of a number of subpar colleges under the Symbiosis umbrella, the value and prestige of SIBM and SCMHRD have declined in the eyes of the general public. 

SIBM and SCMHRD are amazing institutes, but the public might not consider them on par with other prestigious universities due to the above-mentioned reasons.

There is no scale to measure. But if we go by ranking and students' perspectives regarding these colleges. After XLRI/TISS HR, comes MDI followed by SIBM then SCMHRD based on NIRF ranking.

Based on placements, XLRI is the best in HR placements. It also witnesses placements across the world. If you want to pursue a career in Social work and HR then TISS Mumbai is the best. TISS also offers MA programs and it does not offer MBA.

MDI Gurgaon and SCMHRD is also a better option to consider. They have a good alumni base and decent placements at XLRI and TISS.

SIBM Pune, SCMHRD, NMIMS, XIMB, and IIMS belong to the same tier of business institutions. However, there are certain distinctions between SIBM P and SCMHRD.

SIBM Pune is a more established institution with a more extensive and influential Alumni network. It is the premier management institute of Symbiosis International University. School of Photography, Institute of Media and Communication, School of Culinary Arts, Institute of Telecom Management, Institute of Banking and Finance, and School of Sports Sciences share a much larger campus—consequently, a much greater degree of cross-disciplinary exposure.

SIBM has access to a more significant number of competitions than our sister institution.

They improved placement rates for all specializations, including HR. People are typically positioned quicker and with less difficulty than SCMHRD.

Several areas in which you stand to benefit from SCMHRD are the following.

• HUL and PnG have not been recruited from SIBM for several years, whereas they recruit from SCMHRD. However, the annual number of recruits must be larger to impact overall placement statistics significantly.
• The campus in Hinjewadi is closer to a commercial area with simple access to additional stores and eateries.
• A larger HR cohort leads to increased peer-to-peer learning.

Symbiosis International University offers various specializations in MBA.

The choice of institution depends upon the field that you wish to go for. 

1. For Communication Management, you can go for SIMC Pune, which along with MICA, is the best in India for this field.

1. SIBM Pune has the best finance program with CFA accreditation.

1. SCMHRD has the best HR program.It is second to only XLRI. 

1. Marketing is good in both SIBM Pune and SCMHRD.

1. SIIB offers specializations in International Business, Energy & Environment, and Agribusiness. The International Business course offered at SIIB is comparable to IIFT. The other two are unique courses having industry CSR relevance. 

1. SIMS, SSBF, SCIT, and SITM are also good choices that offer unique management courses. For Telecom Management, SITM is a wise choice.

1. If you can go outside Pune, SIBM Bengaluru is also a good choice. It provides great profiles in the IT-ES sector.

1. Also look out for SICSR. Their MBA (IT) program is among the most current and comprehensive programs. SICSR also has the legacy of being the first one to start an MBA in IT specialization. 

These are the various choices according to the stream that you wish to go for. You can choose among them accordingly and go for the institution that best suits your future ambitions.

Between the two, we would enthusiastically recommend SIBM Pune.

SIBM Pune is one of the premier B-schools in India. Since its founding in 1978, it has grown exponentially, producing business leaders who have obtained executive positions.

• Placements: The average placement for 2022 class was INR 26.77 lacs, and the highest package was INR 35.05 lacs (with 111 students receiving PPOs).
• Average Summer Internship placement for 2022 was INR 2.91 Lacs (for two months), with the highest remuneration amounting to INR 4.40 Lacs.
• Infrastructure: SIBM Pune is located on the picturesque hilltop of Lavale and has all the facilities for sports (dedicated cricket, football, basketball ground, and sports complex for Badminton, Tennis, and Table Tennis), fitness (fully equipped gym and a swimming pool! ), a 24-hour library, and the highest number of Bloomberg terminals in the nation.
• Corporate Competitions: SIBM Pune is one of the most sought-after B-schools for corporate competitions that lead to PPIs and PPOs. Students have won the Godrej LOUD, Asian Paints CANVAS, Reckitt Benckiser Global Challenge, Abbott Business Challenge 2.0, Novartis Biocamp Case Study Competition, and ABG HeadstaRt competitions, in addition to reaching the finals in a number of others.
• Students at SIBM Pune come from various backgrounds, assuring racial and cultural diversity. They have students from over 20 states, and from over multiple countries around the world. The philosophy of "Vasudeva Kutumbhakam" ensures that the university remains a family.
• Student-Driven Culture: While many B-schools in India can make this claim, SIBM Pune's student-driven culture is genuinely exceptional. Under the direction of our Director, students manage not only the festivals and sports tournaments but also placements, admissions, and corporate and alumni relations. This may appear elementary to an outsider, but it is an integral aspect of the B-school learning process.

SIBM Pune rates in the top five private B-schools in all rankings and is one of the most desirable B-schools overall.

When considering a post-graduation program in Human Resources, Symbiosis Pune is generally considered to have a better reputation in the market compared to IMT Ghaziabad. This is due to a number of factors, such as the institute's reputation for providing students with a strong foundation in Human Resources through its curriculum, industry-relevant courses, and practical training. Additionally, the institute's alumni network of industry leaders can help students to secure internships and job opportunities post-graduation.

Symbiosis Pune has a strong reputation in the field of Human Resources, with a focus on providing students with an in-depth understanding of the various aspects of the field, such as organizational behavior, employee relations, and talent management. The curriculum is designed to equip students with the skills and knowledge needed to excel in a career in Human Resources. The institute also has a strong network of industry contacts, which helps students to secure internships and job opportunities post-graduation.

On the other hand, if it were marketing, then IMT Ghaziabad would have been a better choice. IMT Ghaziabad is known for its strong marketing program, with a focus on providing students with a comprehensive understanding of the various aspects of marketing, such as consumer behavior, market research, and branding. The institute's curriculum is designed to equip students with the skills and knowledge needed to excel in a career in marketing, and the institute's alumni network of industry leaders can help students to secure internships and job opportunities post-graduation.

When considering a post-graduation program, it's important to research the different options available and weigh the pros and cons of each institute. Researching the institute's curriculum, faculty, and alumni network, as well as speaking to current students and alumni can help you to make an informed decision. Additionally, it would be a good idea to seek the opinion of professionals in the field you are interested in, as they can provide valuable insights into the opportunities and challenges of different career paths.