Choosing the right business school can be a tough decision, especially when you have multiple offers to choose from. Below is a table comparing these colleges on different aspects;
Aspect | Goa Institute of Management (GIM) | Birla Institute of Management Technology (BIMTECH) | Xavier Institute of Social Service (XISS) | (IMT Hyderabad) |
Specializations | General, Healthcare Management, Banking, Financial services & Insurance Management, Big Data Analytics | Marketing, Finance, Operations, etc. | Human Resource Management, Marketing, Finance, Information Technology | Finance, General management, Marketing |
Entrance Exam Accepted | CAT/XAT/GMAT/CMAT | XAT/CAT/CMAT/GMAT/MAT | CAT/XAT/CMAT | CAT/CMAT |
Fees | INR 18.5 lakhs | INR 13 lakhs | INR 8 lakhs | INR 13 lakhs |
Highest Salary | INR 60.4 LPA (International) INR 55 LPA (Domestic) | INR 23.43 LPA | INR 20.50 LPA | INR 20 LPA |
Average Salary | INR 14.87 LPA | INR 11.25 LPA | INR 9.40 LPA | INR 7.64 LPA |
Top Recruiters | Infosys, Deloitte, IBM, Axis Bank, Infosys, Genpact | ADP, Wipro, E&Y, Deloitte, KPMG, Kantar, Yamaha Motors | HDFC, ICICI Bank, Deloitte India, EY, Emami, MTR Foods, etc. | Goldman Sachs, Amazon, Deloitte, D.E Shaw, Berkadia, Guardian Capital, Tresvista Financial Services |
Ultimately the decision is up to you, as it will depend on your goals, preferences, and any constraints you might have. Hope it helps, choose wisely, All the best!
IMT Hyderabad is a better choice than the Xavier Institute of Social Service in Ranchi. The reasons that support the aforementioned statement are listed below
Placement Support – Many giant recruiters visit IMT Hyderabad every year, including KPMG, Deloitte, Amazon, HDFC Bank, ICICI, SBI Life, Syska, Blue Star, CCD, Khmimji Ramdas, Nephro Plus, Fact Set, Care Ratings, S&P Global, iNautix, and so on. The students are given multiple offers with a high CTC.
Here are the placement statistics for IMT Hyderabad-
Particulars |
Placement Statistics 2021-22 |
Recruiters participated |
50+ |
New recruiters participated |
20 |
Placement percentage |
98% |
Highest CTC |
INR 16LPA |
Average CTC |
INR 9.4 LPA |
Faculty – IMT Hyderabad has corporate faculties and one-third of the sessions are conducted by SR leadership
Thus, go with the option IMT Hyderabad for a better educational foundation
According to my friends studying at XIMB RM, the college is not called XIMB RM anymore. The last batch to pass from the college with this college name was the 2015-2017 batch. It has been renamed to Xavier School of Rural Management (XSRM) under the umbrella of Xavier University, Bhubaneshwar.
Categories | XSRM |
Course Fee | 13.8 lakh |
Highest CTC | 13.2 - 17 LPA |
Average CTC | 8-9 LPA |
Recruiting Companies | Amul, Godrej Agrovet Limited, ITC Limited, Mapro Foods, ADM Agro Industries, Tolaram Group, etc. |
As far as XISS Finance is concerned, you should get in touch with a postgraduate student from that college to get to know more about it. As of now, I would suggest you go for XSRM.
One of my friends studied at XISS, I can share some details about this institution. XISS has still not been able to make its name among the top colleges of India despite being such an old institute.
It will be better to avoid XISS and take admission in other B-schools like Army Institute of Management, Kolkata which might provide better facilities and placement opportunities to its students. Do thorough research before making a decision.
Usually, XISS Ranchi cutoff for CAT/XAT stays around 60+. The institute offers four specializations. Here is the 2021 CAT cutoff for different specializations.
Specialization | General |
PGDIT | 85 |
PGDM Marketing | 85 |
PGDM Finance | 85 |
PGDM Human Resource Management | 85 |
Other than CAT/XAT, XISS Ranchi also accepts CMAT scores for admission. The CMAT cutoff stays around 70+.
XISS Ranchi is ranked 76 by NIRF 2020, WESCHOOL Mumbai is ranked 68 by NIRF 2020, SIES Mumbai is ranked 22 by Times 2020, and XIME Bangalore is ranked 56 by India Today for MBA. Given below a brief highlight of the MBA HRM program at these institutes.
XISS Ranchi:
Admission:
Graduate students with above 50% marks in any streams are eligible to apply for the MBA in HRM program at XISS Ranchi.
For getting admission a valid CAT/CMAT/XAT score is required. The applicants are selected on the performance in the entrance exam, group discussion, and personal interview.
The grand total fees are around 10 lacs.
Placements:
The highest salary offered is 14 LPA and the average salary offered is 6 LPA.
The top recruiters include Tata, ICICI, HDFC Mutual fund, Mahindra Finance.
WESCHOOL Mumbai:
Admission:
Admission to the PGDM HRM at WESCHOOL Mumbai is based on CAT/XAT/CMAT/ATMA score, academic performance, work experience, group activity, and personal interview.
Placements:
The highest salary offered is 12 LPA and the average salary offered is 7 LPA.
The top recruiters include Deloitte USI, GEP, Accenture, Nestle, Morgan Stanley.
SIES Mumbai:
Admission:
The basic selection criteria of admission is through the entrance test followed by Group Discussion and Personal Interview.
Applicants applying for admission in SIES need to appear for one of these entrance exams, CAT/MAT /XAT/CMAT /ATMA/MH-CET.
Placements:
The highest salary offered is 18 LPA and the average salary offered is 7 LPA.
Some of the major recruiters at SIEM are Aditya Birla Capital, Phoenix, FCB, KPMG, TCS, MARICO, Philips, Reliance Group.
XIME Bangalore:
Admission:
The students having graduate degrees with 50% and above marks are eligible for admission into the MBA HRM program.
An entrance test score of 75% and above is required in CAT/XAT/GMAT/MAT/ATMA/CMAT.
The grand total fees for studying at Xime is around 10 lacs.
Placements:
The highest salary package offered is 16.5 LPA however, the average salary package is 7 LPA.
The top recruiters include Deloitte, Infosys, Wipro, HDFC Bank.
The placement stats and total fees are similar in all the colleges. The student can choose any of them for an HRM specialization.
International Management Institute Delhi has been ranked 28 for MBA by NIRF 2020. IMI Delhi provides post-graduation management and doctoral courses. It is among the only 5 B-Schools in India with AMBA accreditation. Whereas, XISS Ranchi has a NIRF Ranking of 76 for MBA. Both IMI Delhi and XISS Ranchi offer decent Post Graduate Diploma Management programs in Human Resource Management. It is a 2-year duration course.
Admission:
IMI Delhi-
Applicants need to apply online to the institute website and make the payment of fees.
The applicant must have a bachelor's degree with a minimum of 50% marks in any discipline.
The application process consists of three stages, i.e. shortlisting of candidates on the basis of the performance in the Common Admission Test (CAT) and Graduate Management Test (GMAT), written test scores, and personal interview.
The qualified students are considered for admission on the basis of their overall performance from the above criteria.
XISS Ranchi-
Admission for MBA at XISS through CAT/XAT/GMAT. The institute also conducts written tests and interviews for selection.
The applicants are required to fill the application form online from the official website of the institution.
The application procedure at XISS includes registration from the official website of the institution, uploading of details and documents, payment of application form online of INR 2100.
The grand total fees at the institutes are mentioned below.
Institute |
IMI Delhi |
XISS Ranchi |
Grand total fees |
17 lacs |
10 lacs |
Placement:
IMI Delhi-
100+ companies participate in the recruitment of students from all prominent sectors of the business world.
As per the reports of 2017-2019 placement stats, PGDM HRM had the highest placement package as 13.3 LPA and the average placement package as 11 LPA.
The major recruiters are HDFC Bank, Oyo, Lenskart, Radio Mirchi, Sony pictures, Asian paints, etc.
XISS Ranchi-
78% of students from the Human Resource Management streams got hired by the recruiters.
HRMS is one of the most popular courses under PGDM.
The highest package offered was 14 LPA and the average package offered was 8.5 LPA.
The top recruiters from HRM include Tata, ACC, and Adani group.
For an HRM, The grand total fees at IMI is much greater than XISS. The placements stats are very good in both XISS and IMI, however, the average placement at XISS is better than IMI.
It's hard to make a straightforward comparison between these two institutes as it depends on various factors such as fees, quality of education, infrastructure, program syllabus, ranking, placement opportunities, student intake, diversity, location, and more. Both institutes are reputable and offer management degrees as an end result, but one may come with a lower fee structure while the other may have a higher fee structure. Similarly, one institute may offer better placement opportunities than the other, and the overall comparison can be made based on the mentioned parameters.
XISS Ranchi has a NIRF Ranking of 76 and Bimtech has a NIRF Ranking of 47 for MBA. Bimtech and XISS Ranchi, both offer decent PGDM degree programs in Marketing specializations. Given below is a brief highlight of the MBA program offered by Bimtech and XISS Ranchi.
Parameters |
Bimtech |
XISS |
Grand total fees |
12 Lacs |
10 lacs |
Highest salary package |
18 LPA |
14 LPA |
Average salary package |
8 LPA |
6 LPA |
Admission:
Bimtech:
For PGDM, the applicants must have graduated with a minimum of 50% aggregate at Bimtech.
The candidate is required to have a valid score in CAT/XAT/CMAT/GMAT/MAT.
Applicants are then shortlisted for a personal interview and writing ability test.
The applicants need to fill the online application form from the website of the college and pay the application fee of INR 2000.
XISS Ranchi:
Admission for MBA at XISS through CAT/XAT/GMAT. The institute also conducts written tests and interviews for selection.
The applicants are required to fill the application form online from the official website of the institution. The application procedure at XISS includes registration from the official website of the institution, uploading of details and documents, payment of application form online of INR 2100.
Placements:
The top recruiters at Bimtech include Amazon, KPMG, Infosys, HDFC Bank.
96% of the total students from the Marketing stream got placed. The average placement in Marketing was 6 LPA. The top recruiters at XISS include JSLPS, ICICI, Mahindra Finance, HDFC Mutual fund, Allergen, etc.
In the stream of Marketing, the number of students placed is better in XISS however, the average placement stats are better in Bimtech. Both the colleges are good for Marketing.
XISS has been ranked 76th by NIRF amongst 100 institutes in India 2020. It offers 5 specializations in PGDM courses such as Human Resource Management, Finance, Rural Management, Information Technology, and Marketing.
Admission:
The admissions at XISS are based on a valid score in CAT/XAT/CMAT entrance exam.
In addition to CAT, the university also accepts XAT and CMAT exam scores. CAT entrance exam scores.
Based on the entrance exam scorecard, the students will be shortlisted and further need to appear for admission rounds that include group discussion, writing skill tests, and personal interview.
Seats available for HRM and Rural Management are 75 and Information Technology, Finance, and Marketing Management specializations have 60 seats each.
Of the above, 40% of seats are reserved for ST/SC and Christian candidates (other than ST/SC). The above mentioned 40 percent is with a breakdown as follows: ST - 26%, SC- 6%, and Christians 8%.
Infrastructure:
The institute offers a broad range of facilities to the students. Which includes a well-stocked library with more than 45000 volumes of books is present on campus. Moreover, the library also has Encyclopedias, Journals, Magazines, and Almanacs. It is also equipped with e-library facilities.
State-of-the-art classrooms, conference rooms, sports ground, fitness center, guest house, and cafeteria, computer/IT facility, hostels with 24x7 security, Wi-fi, medical facility with qualified doctors, laboratories are some of the facilities offered.
Placement:
More than 83 companies participated in the campus drive among which 48 recruiters were new.
Overall 285 offers were made with the highest salary of INR 14.50 LPA and an average salary of INR 5.31 LPA.
Some of the top recruiters visiting the campus are Adani Group, Allergan India, Asian Paints Ltd., Cholamandalam Finance, Cognizant, Hindustan Unilever Ltd., L&T Finance, and many more.
Other Key Points:
The total fee for the MBA Program is approximately INR 10 lacs.
Scholarships are available from corporate houses such as Maruti Suzuki, Tata Steel, NTPC, etc.
Moreover, the government of Jharkhand has taken initiatives to offer scholarships and stipends to the students of the reserved category.
Additionally, a loan facility is also available if anyone has to opt for it.
The Xavier Institute of Social Service (XISS) has developed its prominent identity as a hub of excellence in development interventions, management education, consultancy, and research. It offers a portfolio of research, academic, outreach programs, and social involvement.