Having friends in both the institutes, I might be able to help you with the question. Welingkar, Mumbai, and PUMBA are two opposite colleges, and comparing them is the same as comparing the North and South directions.
Categories |
Welingkar, Mumbai |
PUMBA |
Course Fee |
6.8 - 11.04 lakh |
1.33 lakh |
Highest CTC |
18 LPA |
10 LPA |
Average CTC |
6 LPA |
6 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Deloitte, Wipro, Accenture, HCL, etc. |
ZS Associates, Infosys, HP, HCL, etc. |
A year drop will not be a problem. Assuming these pros and cons, decide the University that best suits you.
The campus infrastructure at Welingkar is excellent, with two libraries, three reading halls, and spacious classrooms. The canteen serves good quality food, and there are research labs for students interested in conducting research on various topics.
The academic curriculum is designed to meet industrial requirements and is updated regularly. The faculty members are also well-equipped with current industry knowledge, making it the best education one can receive.
The following table shows the placement data of Welingkar Institute:
Particulars |
2022 |
2023 |
Highest CTC |
INR 18 LPA |
INR 24 LPA |
Average CTC |
INR 10.05 LPA |
INR 12.25 LPA |
Median CTC |
INR 9.83 LPA |
INR 11.59 LPA |
The placement opportunities are outstanding, with many reputed companies and banks visiting for recruitment. The summer internships are also excellent. The visiting companies include Accenture, Airtel, Crisil, Amazon, Cognizant, etc.
The value for money in the college is exceptional, with relatively low course fees compared to other management colleges. The investment is worth it as it can lead to good job opportunities with attractive packages.
The campus life is enjoyable with numerous competitions, events, and activities happening throughout the year.
PUMBA has a decent campus infrastructure with well-equipped classrooms, computer labs, a library, and a hostel facility. The campus has Wi-fi, and students have 24*7 access to high-speed internet.
Particulars |
2020 |
2021 |
Highest Package |
18 |
13.55 |
Average Package |
7.6 |
6.47 |
PUMBA has a strong track record of placements, with many reputed companies visiting the campus for recruitment. The placement process is well-organized, and students have the opportunity to secure internships and full-time job offers from various sectors, including FMCG, IT, BFSI, Consulting, and more. However, the placement scenario may vary for each batch and individual student, and the competition can be tough.
Before joining any college it's better to perform some research on it. The foremost thing is you need to know all the placement details from alumni or the students who are currently studying in that college. Don’t choose a college based only on their advertisement.
Dalmia NL, SIES (MMS), and Welingker(PGDM) all these colleges are well-reputed institutions in Mumbai for management studies. I have friends pursuing their studies at these colleges. Based on what I heard, I will say N L Dalmia is the best college among these three. It has better placement records, ranking, and reputation.
So, N L Dalmia is definitely a better choice. But before making a decision, do your own research first.
NL Dalmia does not follow the exact cutoff criteria. The cutoff ranges from 92 to 95% for the general category. The admission process is based on your score in the entrance examination and the interview conducted by the institute. This institute accepts various entrance examinations like XAT, CAT, CMAT, ATMA, etc. for a PGDM program.
These courses were first inaugurated in the year 2014, and ever since then, students undeniably acquired satisfactory placement offers.
The only separate piece of information this has is that in PGDPM, students are preferred by recruiters if they come with a minimum work experience of about 2 to 3 years.
MBA in Shipping and Port Management is a niche field of study. But this course is in high demand. If you are interested in the field, it doesn’t really matter that it is a specialized field. A graduate in Shipping and Port Management with decent skills makes almost double/triple of their equivalent MBA graduates. The reason for it is the less number of good Maritime professionals.
IMU offers decent MBA courses. The Kolkata campus has a good faculty base. However, you shouldn’t entirely depend on the on-campus placement drive for employment. If you have the required skills, you can easily get placement opportunities.
IIT Kanpur is one of the esteemed engineering and technology institutes in India, and the economics program it is highly reputed. It aims to provide students with a rigorous education in economic theory and its applications. Students also have the opportunity to participate in research projects, internships, and other extracurricular activities.
The course curriculum of the Economics program comprises compulsory foundation subjects in the first year and departmental courses from the second year with microeconomics and macroeconomics being the first two courses you will come across,
Some of the most dynamic courses include Mathematical Economics, and Econometrics 1 and 2. The curriculum is flexible leaving the possibility for pursuing an interest in other fields too apart from Economics through open electives. Those who find the program not aligned with their interests can also opt for branch change after a year.
Education-wise, this program offers many opportunities.
The job opportunities offered by this program are also in abundance
Moreover, IIT Kanpur is the only IIT that has a separate department of Economic Sciences. The dedicated faculty is composed of highly-qualified and experienced economists. The program, being old, has an elaborate alumni pool too.
To begin with, let me tell you that XIMB offers MBA-BM whereas XAHR offers MBA-HRM. XAHR or Xaviers School of Human Resource Management was started after the immense success of the HRM program of XIMB.
Now coming to your question, the program you choose will be an important factor in shaping your career so it should be based on your inclinations. Get a clear idea of the various arenas and specializations of Management and the required skills. Both the courses deal with very important elements of Management but HRM specifically deals with the primary asset of any company, The employees.
BM offers an MBA in various fields like
Each of these specializations have its own pros and cons. For instance, if you are into number crunching, operation management, and market mapping, then BM is a good choice for you. You can get further details of the course on the official website. Analyze what course and why attracts you the most and make an informed decision. So only you can decide which course to take as this is a subjective question based solely on your personal preference.
One of the premier management institutes in Northern India, Doon Business School brings forth an excellent educational experience. The institute offers a rich blend of managerial as well as technology skills so that the students can combine the knowledge they have gained and leverage contemporaneous technologies to gain a formidable competitive edge.
MBA program
The 2-year MBA Programme at Doon Business School is approved by AICTE and affiliated to Uttarakhand Technical University(UTU). The program carefully tackles the students' caliber to become impactful leaders through the skills acquired. The following specializations are offered with MBA
The institute also offers additional value certificates at certain prices. These optional certification programs take place after college hours wherein the students can customize pricing depending on the package they choose.
The students can choose all up to 4/8 programs in 4 semesters and a maximum of 2 in one semester
Faculty
The faculty pool is a combination of excellent academic achievers and immense practical experience. They develop conceptual clarity and assist in the applicability of theoretical knowledge to real-life situations.
Placements
Placements are conducted under the supervision of an experienced Placement Coordinator. The great industry exposure throughout the course makes placements better. The interaction between students and corporates helps develop trust between them and the credibility of the student's knowledge.
Overall, the students get to spend time in a clean and serene environment and this factor is itself a major determinant of a good education.