You should compare these two institutes based on the performance of the branch that you are interested in.
ISM is different from other IITs, in the sense that it is well-recognized for Mining, Geology, Petroleum, and other related branches. Other core branches like CSE, Electronics, etc. started after it got the IIT status. So, the institute will need some time to catch up with IIT BHU for these branches.
While IIT BHU has had many years to establish a brand name for these branches. It also exhibited many high packages over the years. Although the infrastructure at the institute is poor.
So, if you are interested in branches like Mining, Petroleum, etc. then you should choose ISM. For mainstream branches, IIT BHU is better.
You should choose the college closer to your home. Both the colleges DTU and IIT Dhanbad are Tier-1 engineering colleges in India.
Degree Outcome:
Given below is an overview of both the colleges.
Category |
DTU |
IIT Dhanbad |
Average CTC |
INR 10 LPA |
INR 11 LPA |
Course Fee |
7.8 lakhs |
8.8 lakhs |
The more well-grounded and genuine way to become a Mechanical or Automobile Engineer in India is to become proficient in the GATE/ IES ME curriculum and participate in some competitive exams to secure a job in the government sector.
Mechanical engineering is getting outdated and people are not getting in any good place in India by doing Mechanical engineering. This program is even getting shut in various developed countries. So, choose wisely.
ICT Mumbai is a better option for chemical engineering. A friend of mine recommended ICT Mumbai due to certain major reasons listed below:
Therefore, the final choice should be ICT Mumbai for pursuing chemical engineering. Here is a presentation of some of the factual information:
Particulars |
ICT Mumbai |
ISM Dhanbad |
Placement rate(2020) |
70% |
65% |
Average salary package (2020) |
>4.5LPA AND <16.5LPA |
>9LPA AND <43LPA |
Fee structure(2020) |
Rs. 85,350 (for the first year) |
Rs. 8,80,000 |
ICT Mumbai is better than ISM Dhanbad from every aspect. The faculty is well read and has ample domain knowledge. They try their level best to help students with their doubts. I hope the information provided above helps.
All of these colleges have good rankings for their BTech courses and offer good placement opportunities to their engineering students.
A comparison is presented below to explain the factors to be considered while choosing an engineering course from these universities.
Particulars | MNNIT Allahabad – CSE | IIIT Allahabad - IT | DTU - MnC | ISM Dhanbad - CSE |
Fees | INR 3.24 lakhs | INR 5.34 lakhs | INR 7.81 lakhs | INR 8.88 lakhs |
Entrance Criteria | 10+2 in science with 75% & JEE Main | 10+2 in science with 75% & JEE Main | 10+2 in science with 60% & JEE Main | 10+2 in science with 75% & JEE Advanced |
Total Seats | 177 | 223 | 152 | 114 |
Campus Placement:
MNNIT Allahabad –
IIIT Allahabad –
DTU –
Outlook India ranked DTU as 1 college in the placement category.
ISM Dhanbad -
There are numerous placement and scholarship opportunities available in these colleges, however, it depends more on the student’s interest and feasibility.
If you're considering pursuing higher education in engineering, you may be wondering whether to choose IIT Patna or IIT(ISM) Dhanbad. Here's some information that may help you make a decision:
IIT Patna:
IIT(ISM) Dhanbad:
In summary, both IIT Patna and IIT(ISM) Dhanbad have their own advantages and disadvantages. While IIT Patna is located in a major city and has newer infrastructure, it is far from the main city and the weather can be quite hot. On the other hand, IIT(ISM) Dhanbad is located in a smaller city but is closer to the railway station and the main market area. The weather in Dhanbad is cooler and the brand value of the institution is high.
M.Tech Mechanical is a preferred stream but its success is directly proportional to the level of placements offered by colleges in comparison to the fees or investment made. The number of students enrolled is less compared to B.Tech making it a less lucrative option for campus placements.
The detailed analysis is as follows.
Eligibility:
The basic criterion stands at graduation with a minimum score of 50%.
The common examination accepted is GATE.
Fees:
NIT Surathkal has a fee structure of Rs. 1.85 Lakhs
ISM Dhanbad offers the course is Rs. 1.05 Lakhs.
ISM has fewer fees as compared to NIT Surathkal.
Placement Details:
The prime-most details to be focused upon are the average and highest placement scenario of both the colleges in general.
College |
Placement |
NIT Surathkal |
Average-Rs.11.90 LPA, Highest-Rs. 18.75 LPA |
ISM Dhanbad |
Highest-Rs. 12.50 LPA |
79% placements in NIT Surathkal M.Tech as opposed to 50% in ISM.
Major Recruiters are Teradata, Cisco, Dell EMC, Riverbed Technology, and Huawei Technologies.
ISM M.Tech is not preferable for mechanical, it’s a sure shot option in case of CSE or Mineral engineering.
The only reason to prefer ISM is the IIT factor attached to it which makes it more appealing in terms of faculty and culture.
The choice can be made both on the basis of placements and college ranking with respect to the course offered. The packages offered in the Mechanical stream in NIT Surathkal are quite good as compared to those in ISM Dhanbad. NIT Surathkal also holds a reputation in the institutional list with respect to its 7th position in the list of NIT.
For Mining, you should choose ISM. It is the best campus for the branch. The syllabus followed at the institute is rigorous. The research culture is better too. It has the best alumni base in the Mining industry. You will be able to make excellent contacts.
There are many Mining industry headquarters located in Dhanbad. So, it’s easy to get hands-on experience.
The placement averages around 100%. In the recent placement drive, the maximum salaries were offered by Coal India, Caterpillar, etc. which was INR 15-20 LPA.
For a CSE degree, ISM Dhanbad will be the better option among these. It has a higher cutoff for CSE. For 2021, the cutoff for CSE at ISM Dhanbad, IIT Bhubaneswar, and IIT Gandhinagar was 907-2968, 1621-2304, 1230-1519, respectively.
ISM Dhanbad CSE average package is INR 15 LPA. ISM is older than IIT Bhubaneswar and IIT Gandhinagar and has a large well-developed alumni base. You will get good networking opportunities.
The electrical engineering department received the second-highest CTC of 39 LPA from IIT ISM Dhanbad. Around 76% of the ECE students got placements in top companies namely Flipkart, Accenture, Wipro, etc.
The School of Electrical Sciences in IIT Bhubaneswar received the highest placement record. The students got placed in Microsoft company last year with the highest package and average package of 38 LPA and 11 LPA respectively. Moreover, a good number of Core companies, software companies hire electrical engineers from IIT Bhubaneswar. A total of 86% of students got placed from EEE in 2019 placement.
ISM Dhanbad is the better choice than IIT Bhubaneswar because of its better campus infrastructure and large alumni base as it is the older institute.
IIT BHU, as well as IIT/ISM Dhanbad both, are the old institutes that were recently converted to IITs. So both have a prestigious status through IIT BHU performed better than the ISM in the 2020 NIRF Rankings- IIT BHU(11), and ISM(12).
Talking about the branch, Electrical at IIT BHU includes only the core electrical subjects. Moreover, there are very few companies visiting for core electrical students. Although, the students can sit for IT companies during the placement drive. According to 2019 placement highlights, a total of 88 students got placed from the Electrical Engineering at IIT BHU. The salary package ranged between 10 LPA to 58.21 LPA.
On the other hand, CSE offers many job options and more scope than electrical since every other field is getting blended with the CSE nowadays. And, ISM holds decent placement records for the CSE branch. The placement highlights of 2019 show there was a 90.23% placement from CSE and the average CTC offered was 39.5 LPA.